Edit

Netanyahu’s electoral Houdini act: polls missed the mark, stalemate favours the incumbent

Despite being framed as a referendum on his leadership after 7 October, Benjamin Netanyahu emerged stronger than predicted

Dick Roche EUalive November 2, 2026 06:20

In Israel’s electoral history, no party has ever secured an outright majority in a Knesset election. Despite all the hype in the run-up to last week’s general election, that remains the case. In today’s piece for EUalive Dick Roche, Ireland’s former Minister for European Affairs,  takes a detailed look at  Israel’s general election, its two lead players, and what comes next.

EUalive’s columnist Dick Roche is a former Irish Minister for European Affairs. His columns can be found here.

The results of Israeli 26th General election released on 30 October show that opinion polls published during the election campaign significantly underestimated the political strength of  Benjamin Netanyahu and the parties supporting him. They also overestimated the performance of the Change Bloc headed by Gadi Eisenkot’s and failed to anticipate the success  of the electoral mobilisation campaign amongst  Arab voters.

In the coming days the complicated job of bringing together the 61 Knesset members needed to support the formation Israel’s next government gets underway. That could take weeks and could well end with another general election.

While the election –  widely framed as a ‘Referendum on Netanyahu’ – denied ‘Bibi’ the 61 seats needed to continue as Prime Minister, it left him in the ‘driver’s seat for the coming months and also put him in a position where if another general election must be called he is likely to be in a better position than he was going into the voting on 27th October.

Israel’s complicated elections

In Israeli general elections, votes are cast for party lists rather than for individual candidates. The Knesset’s 120 members are elected for a single national constituency. After are cast the 120 seats in the Knesset are allocated on a proportional basis amongst the political parties that receive more than 3.25 per cent of the valid votes cast in the elections.

The lack of a clear winner in a Knesset election is nothing new. The closest to an outright Knesset majority result in a general election was in October 1969, when an alliance of centre-left parties headed by Golda Meir won 56 seats, five seats short of an overall majority.  Following the election Golda Meir negotiated additional support from parties outside her group – including from the right leaning bloc headed by Menachem Begin – which gave her the additional support needed to comfortably win the post of Prime Minister.

With the exception of the 1996, 1999 and 2001 elections, when Israel experimented with direct elections for Prime Minister, post-election wrangling to assemble a coalition commanding the support of at least 61 members of the 120-seat Knesset is the norm in Israeli.

An electoral Houdini

Benjamin Netanyahu was first elected to the Knesset in 1988. Prior to becoming a  Knesset Member Netanyahu served, from 1984 to 1988, as Israel’s Ambassador and Permanent Representative to the United Nations, a post that brought him  to public prominence. He became leader of the Likud party in 1993. Three years later he became Israel’s first directly elected Prime Minister. He contested but lost the 1999 Prime Ministerial election.

Following that election Netanyahu resigned as Likud leader and withdrew from the Knesset. Three years later he was back in office as Minister for Foreign Affairs in the Government of Ariel Sharon. In late 2005 Sharon left Likud following a bitter internal dispute over the withdrawal of Israeli settlements from Gaza. Netanyahu reassumed the Likud leadership.

The general elections of  2009, 2013, 2015, 2020 and 2022 saw Netanyahu returned as Prime Minister: he hammered out coalition deals following each election. In 2009 , Likud won fewer seats than Sharon ‘s Kadima party, but Netanyahu secured sufficient support to form a government.

While Netanyahu has attracted negative headlines and accumulated plenty of political enemies over the years he has been extraordinarily effective in the post-election wrangling that produces Israeli Prime Ministers – an electoral Houdini. That record will be tested in the weeks ahead.

The referendum on Netanyahu

Israel’s 26th general election has been framed by his opponents as a referendum on Netanyahu and the security failings of 7 October 2023 when over 1,200 people were killed by Hamas and other Iranian backed armed groups in their homes and settlements,  where families died in horrific circumstances in ‘safe rooms’ meant to protect them, in a massacre at the Nova music festival and where a further 251 people taken as hostage – 85 of whom did not survive.

Two days before voting – over 100,000 people gathered in Tel Aviv’s Hostages Square to reiterate demands for a state commission of inquiry into the failures surrounding the Hamas-led attacks. The rally was attended by the leaders of the principal opposition parties who blamed Netanyahu for the fact that a state inquiry has not been held.

The election was not just focused on 7 October. The economy was also on the ‘election agenda’.  While unemployment in Israel is low and the currency and stock market have been performing strongly, the  economy and the cost of living were election issues.  Rapidly rising food and fuel costs, housing affordability and concerns about the long term impacts of defence spending were particular triggers for voters. A poll published in the Jerusalem Post on 19 October records  34per cent of voters as seeing the economy as their main concern. Concern about the cost of living and the economy is particularly high amongst opposition aligned voters

Military conscription and in particular the exemptions available to ultra-Orthodox Jews was a very ‘Israeli’ issue in the election.  For decades, many ultra-Orthodox Jewish men studying in yeshivas –religious academies devoted to the study of Jewish religious texts have been exempt from military service. A ruling in 2024 from Israel’s Supreme Court ruled that there was no valid statutory basis for a blanket exemption from military service. The outgoing Netanyahu government effectively ignored the ruling, a position deeply resented by many who serve in the IDF, military reservists and their families.

A court case against Netanyahu on charges of bribery, fraud and breach of trust – all of which he denies – also featured in the election campaign. No verdict has been reached in the case which has been underway since 2020 and is unlikely to be resolved anytime soon. In November 2025 Mr Netanyahu requested President Herzog to issue a pardon in the case to end the proceedings. President Herzog declined, suggesting instead that a plea agreement be negotiated.

Eisenkot : Netanyahu’s challenger

The main challenge to Netanyahu in the elections came from former Israeli military chief Gadi Eisenkot.

Eisenkot served as Chief of the General Staff of the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) between 2015 and 2019 – he was selected for the position by Benjamin Netanyahu. On retiring from the military, Eisenkot joined National Unity, a centrist alliance led by Benny Gantz. He was elected to the Knesset in the 2022 general election. Following the 7 October 2023 attacks, Eisenkot and Gantz both joined the emergency wartime cabinet formed by Netanyahu-  Gantz as  a full voting member and Eisenkot as a non-voting member. Both resigned in June 2024 citing disagreements with Netanyahu about the direction of the Gaza war and plans for the post-war period. Eisenkot accused Netanyahu of delaying the IDF offensive in Rafah by three months, partly to accommodate far-right coalition partners. Netanyahu’s Likud disputes that allegation.

In June 2025, Eisenkot announced his departure from National Unity and from the Knesset. In September 2025 he established Yashar described as a  centrist security-focused and Zionist party positioned slightly to the left of Likud.  Yashar proposes to establish universal military service for all Israeli citizens, to establish a state commission to examine security failures on 7th October  and to enact a formal written constitution for Israel.

During the election Eisenkot emphasized his security credentials citing his “Dahiyeh doctrine”. The ‘doctrine’ – a strategy Eisenkot created while commander of the IDF’s Northern Command – provides that overwhelming and deliberately disproportionate military force be used against areas from which attacks on Israel are launched. In a 2008 interview Mr Eisenkot said “villages from which Hezbollah operated were not civilian villages but military bases” and would be treated as such,  explaining such actions would deter  future attacks and shorten conflicts.

Other positions espoused by Eisenkot have attracted less attention outside Israel than perhaps they deserve. He has indicated opposition to the two state solution suggesting that after the 7th October anyone still believing in the idea is “delusional”. He has  described Palestinian statehood as ‘irrelevant”.

On the issue of the left bank and illegal settlements Eisenkot favours Jewish settlements but insists that settlements should serve Israeli national interests and must be “legal”. He has been critical of settler violence.

When questioned about working with Israel’s Arab parties Eisenkot suggested that they would first need to subscribe to four principles: recognise Israel as “a Jewish, democratic and liberal state,” commit to the values of Israel’s Declaration of Independence, accept the requirement of mandatory military, national or civilian service for all citizens (Jews, Arabs, and ultra-Orthodox Jews), and recognition that Hamas is a terrorist organisation whose military and governing capabilities must be dismantled”.. When pressed on the issue Eisenkot added “ I do not see any Arab party that accepts the four principles.”

Results: high turnout and flawed polls

More than 5.7 million people voted in the elections, a turnout of 77.9 per cent, the highest in three decades. Between 60,000 and 70,000  Israelis reportedly returned from abroad to cast their votes.

Official tally results show a dramatic increase in voter turnout in Arab communities. The two ‘Arab-led’ electoral lists, combined attracted almost 835,000 votes, an increase of around 64 per cent on 2022. The increase in turnout followed a mobilisation campaign  which drew negative comments from Mr Netanyahu as ‘foreign interference.’ The results will raise Arab party numbers  in the Knesset rise from 10 to 19 seats placing the Arab parties in a potentially pivotal position in the negotiations to form Israel’s next government.

High participation of younger voters was another notable feature of the election.  Days before the voting, BBC reporting suggested that more than half a million first-time voters were expected to participate. Many of the younger voters turned  out to support right-wing parties.

The election  results released by Israel’s Central Elections Committee show that opinion polls published during the election campaign significantly underestimated the strength of the parties supporting Benjamin Netanyahu, overestimated the performance of Gadi Eisenkot’s Change Bloc and failed to anticipate the extent of the electoral mobilisation of Arab voters.

The final polls issued before voting projected that Netanyahu’s Likud party would win between 19 and 21 seats. It secured 27. His coalition bloc generally projected to win around 50 seats won 53 seats.

Gadi Eisenkot’s Yashar party was projected to win between 22 and 23 Knesset seats in the final opinion polls: it won 21 seats. Eisenkot’s Change Group was projected to win between 52 and 56 seats in pre-election polling. It won 48 seats thirteen short of the 61 seats needed to elect a Prime Minister.

What next

As no political bloc secured the 61 seats required for a Knesset majority, President Herzog will consult the political parties and then assign the task of forming a government to a Knesset member. The first candidate has 28 days – with a possible extension of up to 14 days – to bring forward proposals for a government capable of winning the Knesset’s confidence. If that attempt fails, the President may appoint a second candidate, who has 28 days. If this also fails, a final 21-day period opens during which 61 Knesset members  (MKs)  may jointly request, in writing, that the President assign the task to a candidate of their choice. That candidate has 14 days to form a government. If no government emerges, the Knesset is dissolved and an election must be held within 90 days.

Assuming Eisenkot retains the support of the 48 MKs elected under the Change Group banner, he needs a further 13 to reach the 61-seat threshold to form a majority government.  The most obvious source of the necessary votes is the Arab-majority parties. Securing their support comes with  political challenges. Eisenkot has said that he does not consider any Arab party meets the four principles he has laid down for participation in government. Three of the four parties in his own bloc have ruled out forming a government with Arab parties.

Arab party leaders have shown willingness to explore an arrangement with Eisenkot. However supporting a government led by Eisenkot – one of the architects of the Dahiya doctrine, who rejects the two-state solution and advocates continued Israeli security control of the West Bank – would carry significant political costs for an Arab party. The party would have to explain to constituents how supporting Eisenkot would advance Palestinian political aspirations and the interests of Arab citizens of Israel. Equally, any substantial concessions to secure Arab support could prove difficult for Eisenkot to sell to his own supporters.

While Netanyahu is just eight votes short of a Knesset majority, finding those votes will be very difficult. Defections from within the Change Bloc at that level seems improbable. An arrangement with an Arab party would be unacceptable to Netanyahu’s current partners: the risks outweigh the benefits.

Stalemate plays to Netanyahu’s advantage. Without an agreement he will remain as caretaker prime minister until an election is called.

In the election just fought the stars aligned for the Change Bloc. It was the first election after 7 October. Netanyahu’s failings on that day were front and centre in the campaign. His failure to establish an enquiry into the security became a key campaign  issue. Allegations that he failed to prioritise the release of hostages held in Gaza, that he prolonged the war there and that he was responsible for the drop in Israel’s international standing also played to the  advantage of his opponents. In addition corruption allegations Netanyahu has been facing got another ‘airing’. The economic woes facing incumbent parties in elections everywhere provided additional ammunition for his opponents.

These issues helped trigger record turnouts. Tens of thousands flew into Israel to vote. Arab party support rocketed as a result of a highly successful turnout campaign.  In spite of the headwinds facing  Netanyahu Eisenkot coalition failed to make it to the magic 61 seats in the Knesset.

Having weathered the storm, Netanyahu and his coalition have reason to anticipate that they  could perform better in another election early next year than they did on 27 October. At this point holding out for another election may well be Netanyahu’s best game plan for political survival. As he has demonstrated time and again Netanyahu is a master at survival.

Caption: Israeli right-wing activists and supporters of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu demonstrate demanding new elections, in Haifa, Israel, 1 November 2026. The Israeli legislative election held on 27 October resulted in a political deadlock, with no bloc securing the 61-seat outright majority required to form a government in the 120-seat Knesset. EPA/ATEF SAFADI

Updated: November 2, 2026 - 06:20

More from Israel

More from Society

More from Catch the Eye

Subscribe to our

daily newsletter

EUAlive Logo

Subscribe